Should You Move Your Blog to Substack? It Depends What You Want — Followers or Buyers
Clients and readers have been asking me a version of the same question lately. Should I move my blog to Substack? Some are still deciding. Others have already moved and are wondering if it was the right call.
The right decision for you depends on if you want to build a list of readers or buyers, and that's what I'm unpacking in this article.
— In this article —
Is Substack a blog or a newsletter?
It can function as both, but in practice it behaves much more like a newsletter.
Your writing is sent to inboxes first, and your growth depends on people choosing to subscribe and continue receiving what you publish.
That’s different to a blog on your own website, where your content exists independently and can be found without someone needing to opt in first.
Substack sits somewhere between a blog and a newsletter, which is part of what makes it so appealing. But the way it’s used tends to pull you toward a newsletter model.
When I first discovered Substack I fell in love with it. I loved the simplicity of the platform, the grassroots feel, and the audio feature completely won me over. I even experimented with the platform briefly for a small passion project.
But I never used it for my business.
That is because Substack is built on a fundamentally different audience‑building model than the Quiet Marketing Ecosystem I teach.
Substack centres around growing a subscriber base through consistent newsletter publishing.
Readers subscribe to receive your writing
Most join on a free tier
Some creators offer paid subscriptions
Essentially you're building a base of subscribers who follow your writing.
For those that take the paid subscription model and publish on a consistent basis, this can become a meaningful income generator.
How Substack's Recommendation Feature Works
Substack has its own form of discoverability. Articles can appear in search results, and the platform actively recommends other newsletters to readers based on who they subscribe to.
This recommendation feature is so effective that many people end up subscribing to multiple publications in a single sitting — which is great for discovery.
However, what ends up happening is that their inbox can fill with several Substack emails each week. And that starts to feel like too much, so readers begin filtering those emails or unsubscribing.
As a result your writing is competing inside a crowded inbox.
How a Quiet Marketing Ecosystem works
The approach I teach works differently.
Instead of focusing on building subscribers first, the goal is to create discoverable content that introduces people to your work at the moment they are actively looking for answers and support that you provide.
This content lives publicly on the internet. People can find it through search, recommendations, or AI tools without needing to hand over their email address.
From there, the path usually looks like this:
Someone discovers your work
They follow the trail to an accessible paid offer
That experience gives them a meaningful taste of you and your work
What this creates is an email list of buyers, not just subscribers.
People join your world through a purchase. They already understand your perspective and have experienced how you work. Many of them naturally continue on to buy your larger or signature offer without needing to be persuaded or convinced.
Do you want buyers or subscribers?
Substack can work extremely well for writers, journalists, commentators, and creators whose primary product is their ongoing writing.
But if your goal is to build a service‑based business with offers, programs, or client work, the Quiet Marketing Ecosystem tends to create a much stronger foundation.
The focus is not on subscriber growth. It is on discoverability, alignment, and building a list made up of people who have already chosen to invest in your work.
Substack follows a membership-style model
When I looked closely at the Substack model, I realised that the paid subscription route creates many of the same pressures as the membership model.
Which is exactly why I previously wrote an article called “A Case Against The Membership Model.”
That style of business can absolutely work.
There are writers on Substack earning significant income, but it relies on building a large subscriber base, often thousands or tens of thousands of readers — and maintaining a steady rhythm of publishing that keeps people engaged enough to stay.
Which means the income is closely tied to continued output and attention. For some people, that’s a great fit. For many service‑based solopreneurs, it starts to feel like a content hamster wheel.
If your goal is to build a list of readers, then Substack is a beautiful platform to do that.
For the kind of businesses I support, publishing content assets like blog articles on your own website means that people are close to your offers. It also increases the amount of time spent on your website, a metric that search engines use to assess how they will rank you in search queries.
If you’d love my support with creating your own quiet marketing ecosystem, start here.
Finally, I’d love to know what’s been most useful for you here. Let me know in the comments. ⤵
Danielle Gardner
The Quiet Marketer
View my bio
